h1

5 Centimeters per Second Review

October 14, 2008

Finally, I finished the film that has been sitting on my list for a few years.

Byōsoku Go Senchimētoru looks just like other Shinkai films: plenty of beautiful backgrounds and crudely drawn characters. Some scenes are poignant and set up very well, yet we also see some gratuitous imagery. It is important to establish a proper atmosphere, but many of the shots are present just to show off his skill in background design. However, he does employ variety of perspectives that accentuate emotions of the characters well.

The music is very subtle and appropriate, but doesn’t augment the animation significantly. The popular song “One more time, one more chance” (Masayoshi Yamazaki, 1997) was very well selected for the finale because it reflected the feelings of the protagonist. Also I liked piano melody played during the credits.

The film involves many themes including unrequited love, the barriers of space, and nature of communication. The story is divided into three episodes, each focusing on a life period of the protagonist and narrated mostly in monologues.

The first episode tells us how Akari and Takaki became friends and developed strong feelings to each other. Unfortunately, Takaki has to relocate and wants to meet with Akari one last time. The trip is delayed by a snow storm and causes much anxiety to Takaki. They do meet eventually, and we see one of the best scenes in the movie under the cherry tree. Even during such a great moment, Takaki realizes that this too shall pass, they will not be together forever. He moves to another city, but promises to write to Akari. Shinkai executed this episode quite well, but it is all downhill from now on.

The second episode brings a new girl, Kanae, in Takaki’s life. She is in love with him, but has difficulty confessing. One day she decides to do it, but does not accomplish her plan because she realizes that Takaki was always looking somewhere else, still preoccupied by the memory of his childhood and his love for Akari. Despite that, Kanae still loves Takaki hopelessly. We don’t see any further development and jump suddenly several years to the future.

The third episode is set in the current day. Takaki has work and girlfriend now, but he still loves Akari, he still lives in the past. He buried himself in work ignoring his feelings, and only recently he realized how much pain it caused him and how stiff his heart has become. He quits his job and reunites with his girlfriend. Takaki sends her a message that demonstrates his newly gained insight: 1000 messages can’t bring two hearts closer together even by one centimeter. Physical proximity is essential for any successful relationship. This episode feels especially rushed compared to the previous ones, and the ending sequence was even worse.

The ending sequence shows how Takaki and Akari were growing up and eventually lost communication with each other. We see Akari trying to write a letter to Takaki, but she can’t do it because the feeling has faded, and we see empty mail boxes on each side. They found new friends, lovers, graduated from school and started work. Takaki left Kanae eventually, but she goes on with her life as we see Kanae taking her path, riding away on the motorcycle. Akari is engaged and will marry soon, while Takaki is with his girlfriend again. The last few shots show us a scene reminiscent of the beginning of the movie. Takaki passes the train tracks by Akari, looks back, but the train separates the two people. He waits till the trains pass and finds that the woman is gone. He is somewhat disappointed, but turns around. smiles, and keeps going, moving on with his life and leaving his past behind.

The conclusion is supposed to show us the resolution of the story or the follow up on the lives of the main characters. The ending sequence accomplishes this goal to some extent, but we see some events that were never shown in the movie, and it feels somewhat cheap as it seems they were put there because he didn’t have time or skill to integrate them properly into the main story. Here is how to make good ending sequences: (Spoiler Warning!) Hayao Miyazaki, Kiki’s Delivery Service; Isao Takahata, Only Yesterday.

Ending Sequence

Music Video

Overall, while I have some complaints about the film, it did touch me and made me think because the story reminded me of some of the events in my own life…

Related Posts:

5 Centimeters per Second Novel

About these ads

17 comments

  1. You’re right – it’s not perfect, but it does make you think and reflect on your own life.

    I liked the movie cause it was peaceful, and yet sort of bittersweet. It doesn’t have that perfect ending that one may want, and it’s sort of like slamming reality into someone’s face. … It also has really good animation. :]


    • very well said. my thoughts exactly.


  2. Yes, I also liked the movie, and it made me think about my life…

    All Shinkai’s films are beautiful, and this one featured some of the best art so far.


  3. i wished that it had some form of a positive resolution, but it was pretty :)


  4. Well, the resolution was somewhat positive because Takaki finally moved on with this life, but I see what you mean – a happier ending might have been more satisfying, yet less realistic.


  5. I was just reading yesterday,link , that this movie cost under $250,000 to make.

    I’ve watched 5 CM/S three times now and it got better each time I’ve watched it. I still think of it, though, as a good show that has it’s flaws. If the third part had explained things a little better and didn’t feel like a rush then I probably would have liked it more.


  6. Thank you for telling about this interesting comparison :) A little over 200K is a relatively small budget indeed. However, 30K for Perfect Blue? O_o Where they working for free?

    Yes, it is good, but far from perfect. Every new Shinkai’s film does show improvement though. I wonder what he’ll do next upon his return to Japan in 2009 from his vacation in London.


  7. Well, the anime just expressed reality, even though how sad the truth is, everything has an end T.T…


  8. Indeed, it was nice to see a realistic story. While everything has an end, this end can also be a new beginning :)


  9. You should look at the extras, especially the interviews, if you have the DVD. There were supposed to be more stories (up to 9 if I remember correctly) but Mr. Shinkai didn’t want it to be sequences of 15 minutes.

    An excellent movie that will remain a top favorite.

    The ending theme is just plain epic… always tugging my heartstrings and bringing tears to my eyes.


  10. Oh, up to nine stories even? That is interesting, thank you for mentioning that :) Usually, it is best to tell the story the way you want and don’t worry about the time it will take. Of course, due to some constraints from the industry, the work has to remain relatively short. However, some of the best directors took their time anyway: Seven Samurai (207 min), Andrei Rublev (210 min).

    Yes, the ending song was very good :)


  11. The ending theme was very nice on its own, although I didn’t think it was a good match for the closing scenes. (Thematically, yes, but not stylistically.) I think an instrumental score would have worked better.

    I’m not complaining loudly, though. The end result was still very good.

    Side note: So, how’s PollDaddy working out for you? Haven’t tried it myself, actually.


  12. Yes, an instrumental score might have worked well :)

    I’ve been using PollDaddy for a few months now and quite pleased with the results. I love surveys and polls myself, and the results also allow me to see the opinions of my readers. Of course, you have to take the results with a block of salt, but still, they do provide interesting information and make the blog more interactive :) Some creative use of polls includes character propaganda :P Recent integration of PollDaddy into WordPress makes the poll creation even easier :)


  13. I found an interesting summary of the 5 cm/sec novel and updated my post with a link. The novel might clarify some issues :)


  14. [...] Related Posts: 5 cm/sec Review [...]


  15. [...] Related Post: 5 cm/sec Review [...]


  16. [...] My review.. [...]



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 92 other followers

%d bloggers like this: